BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//jEvents 2.0 for Joomla//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Singapore
BEGIN:STANDARD
DTSTART:20100725T170000
RDATE:20380119T111407
TZOFFSETFROM:+0800
TZOFFSETTO:+0800
TZNAME:Asia/Singapore +08
END:STANDARD
BEGIN:STANDARD
DTSTART:20380119T111407
TZOFFSETFROM:+0800
TZOFFSETTO:+0800
TZNAME:Asia/Singapore +08
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
UID:ec7453994530cebac8822649309049ba
CATEGORIES:Seminar
CREATED:20160413T114048
SUMMARY:The Dallah Debate and its Implications
LOCATION:Maxwell Chambers\, Raffles Room (Level 3) 
DESCRIPTION:About the Seminar:\nOn 17 February 2011, in Governement du Pakistan – Minis
 tère des affaires religieuses v. Société Dallah Real Estate and Tourism Hol
 ding Company (Case No. 09/28553), the Paris Court of Appeal rejected an app
 lication by the Government of Pakistan to set aside three ICC awards render
 ed in Paris, holding that the arbitral tribunal was correct in finding it h
 ad jurisdiction over the Government despite it not being signatory to the a
 rbitration agreement.\nThe Paris Court of Appeal’s decision stands in stark
  contrast to a unanimous decision of the UK Supreme Court rendered just thr
 ee months earlier, on 3 November 2010. The UK Supreme Court, applying Frenc
 h law, concluded that "there was no material sufficient to justify the trib
 unal's conclusion" that the Government was a party to the arbitration agree
 ment and therefore refused to enforce the award in the UK.\nIn other words,
  the court of the place of enforcement (UK Supreme Court) and the court of 
 the seat (Paris Court of Appeal) applied French law to the same facts but a
 rrived at different conclusions. This reignited debate within the internati
 onal arbitration community on a broad range of topics, including the reason
 s for and implications of this difference, on the principle of competence-c
 ompetence as well as the enforcement of awards under the New York Conventio
 n.\nWhat are the implications of the courts of the seat and the courts of t
 he places of enforcement reaching differing views on jurisdiction? Did the 
 UK and French courts adopt divergent approaches or did they simply have dif
 ferent opinions? How does this relate to our understanding of the theory of
  international arbitration? What lessons or insights can be drawn from thes
 e decisions?\nThe SIArb is honoured to host a panel discussion presided ove
 r by Attorney-General Sundaresh Menon during which these questions and othe
 r aspects of the ‘Dallah Debate’ will be explained and addressed. A signifi
 cant portion of the seminar will take the form of an open forum discussion 
 so participants are encouraged to read the relevant judgments before attend
 ing.\nProgramme and Format:\n5.00pm  Registration and Coffee\n5.30pm  Intro
 duction by Peter Leaver QC\n5.50pm  Comments by Professor Emmanuel Gaillard
 \n6.10pm  Observations by Attorney General Sundaresh Menon\n6.20pm  Panel D
 iscussion followed by Q&amp;A\n7.00pm  Closing Remarks\n7.10pm  Networking 
 and Refreshments\nAbout the Chairman:\nMr Menon, graduated with Bachelor of
  Laws (First Class Honours) from the National University of Singapore in 19
 86 and later obtained a Master of Laws degree from Harvard Law School in 19
 91. He was admitted as an advocate and solicitor of the Supreme Court of Si
 ngapore in 1987 and as an Attorney and Counsellor-at-law of the Bar of the 
 State of New York in 1992. He was appointed Senior Counsel in January 2008.
 \nMr Menon is recognised as one of the leading lawyers in the fields of com
 mercial litigation and arbitration, insolvency and construction law, in Sin
 gapore and abroad. He has advised and represented numerous local and overse
 as clients in complex and technical disputes and served in arbitration trib
 unals in various jurisdictions.\nFrom April 2006 to March 2007, Mr Menon se
 rved as a Judicial Commissioner of the Supreme Court. After his stint at th
 e Bench, he returned to Rajah &amp; Tann becoming the Managing Partner of t
 hat firm in August 2009, a position he held until his appointment as the At
 torney-General on 1 October 2010.\nDuring his term as Judicial Commissioner
 , he presided over several prominent criminal and civil cases in the High C
 ourt. He has also served as the Deputy Chairman of the Singapore Internatio
 nal Arbitration Centre and has represented Singapore at UNCITRAL.\nAbout th
 e Speaker:\nEmmanuel Gaillard has represented corporations, States and Stat
 e-owned entities in international arbitration matters for over 25 years. He
  has also acted as sole arbitrator, party-appointed arbitrator or chairman 
 under most international arbitration rules, and is frequently called upon t
 o appear as expert witness on arbitration law issues in international arbit
 ration proceedings or enforcement actions before domestic courts.\nThrough 
 his practice, extensive writing and teaching, Emmanuel Gaillard has signifi
 cantly contributed to the shaping of contemporary international arbitration
  law. His publications include Fouchard Gaillard Goldman On International C
 ommercial Arbitration (1999), a leading treatise on international arbitrati
 on, La Jurisprudence du CIRDI (2 volumes, 2004 and 2010), a commentary on I
 CSID case law; and the first essay on the legal theory of international arb
 itration, based on his Course at The Hague Academy of International Law (As
 pects philosophiques du droit de l'arbitrage international, 2008; Legal The
 ory of International Arbitration, 2010; Teoría Legal del Arbitraje Internac
 ional, 2010). Emmanuel Gaillard is a Professor of Law at Paris XII Universi
 ty. He heads Shearman &amp; Sterling LLP's International Arbitration practi
 ce.\nPeter Leaver is an experienced international commercial arbitrator, re
 commended in Chambers and Partners and The Legal 500. He is a member of the
  Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (MCIArb) and appointed to The Law Socie
 ty’s Accreditation Panel of Arbitrators.\nThrough his extensive practice at
  the Bar, Peter Leaver is experienced in banking, insurance and financial s
 ervices cases, and related jurisdictional questions. He was a director of I
 MRO between 1994 and 2000, and a Deputy Chairman of the Regulatory Decision
 s Committee of the Financial Services Authority until 2005. He is a Deputy 
 High Court Judge. He was a member of a SIB Working Party on the responsibil
 ities of Senior Executives, and was on the Selection Panel for the F.S.A. O
 mbudsman Board. Between 1997 and 1999 he took a sabbatical from the Bar and
  was Chief Executive of the F.A. Premier League.\nIn addition to his experi
 ence in international commercial arbitration, Peter Leaver is an experience
 d arbitrator in the sports sector. He is a member of the Court of Arbitrati
 on for Sport and was appointed as the only British member of the Court of A
 rbitration for Sport Adhoc Tribunal for UEFA 2000 and 2004, and the FIFA Wo
 rld Cup 2006. He was appointed as a member of the Ad-hoc Division of the Co
 urt of Arbitration for Sport for the Salt Lake City Olympic Winter Games 20
 02 and for the Turin Olympic Winter Games 2006. He is also appointed to the
  Chairman’s List of the Sports Dispute Resolution Panel (SDRP). He is Chair
 man of the Board of the London Court of International Arbitration, and the 
 President of the National Anti-Doping Panel. Peter Leaver has a working kno
 wledge of French.\nDownload Brochure HERE (images/Events/Seminar20110726.pd
 f)\n
X-ALT-DESC;FMTTYPE=text/html:<p><strong>About the Seminar:</strong></p><p style="text-align: justify;">O
 n 17 February 2011, in Governement du Pakistan – Ministère des affaires rel
 igieuses v. Société Dallah Real Estate and Tourism Holding Company (Case No
 . 09/28553), the Paris Court of Appeal rejected an application by the Gover
 nment of Pakistan to set aside three ICC awards rendered in Paris, holding 
 that the arbitral tribunal was correct in finding it had jurisdiction over 
 the Government despite it not being signatory to the arbitration agreement.
 </p><p style="text-align: justify;">The Paris Court of Appeal’s decision st
 ands in stark contrast to a unanimous decision of the UK Supreme Court rend
 ered just three months earlier, on 3 November 2010. The UK Supreme Court, a
 pplying French law, concluded that "there was no material sufficient to jus
 tify the tribunal's conclusion" that the Government was a party to the arbi
 tration agreement and therefore refused to enforce the award in the UK.</p>
 <p style="text-align: justify;">In other words, the court of the place of e
 nforcement (UK Supreme Court) and the court of the seat (Paris Court of App
 eal) applied French law to the same facts but arrived at different conclusi
 ons. This reignited debate within the international arbitration community o
 n a broad range of topics, including the reasons for and implications of th
 is difference, on the principle of competence-competence as well as the enf
 orcement of awards under the New York Convention.</p><p style="text-align: 
 justify;">What are the implications of the courts of the seat and the court
 s of the places of enforcement reaching differing views on jurisdiction? Di
 d the UK and French courts adopt divergent approaches or did they simply ha
 ve different opinions? How does this relate to our understanding of the the
 ory of international arbitration? What lessons or insights can be drawn fro
 m these decisions?</p><p style="text-align: justify;">The SIArb is honoured
  to host a panel discussion presided over by Attorney-General Sundaresh Men
 on during which these questions and other aspects of the ‘Dallah Debate’ wi
 ll be explained and addressed. A significant portion of the seminar will ta
 ke the form of an open forum discussion so participants are encouraged to r
 ead the relevant judgments before attending.</p><p style="text-align: justi
 fy;"><strong>Programme and Format</strong>:</p><p style="text-align: justif
 y;">5.00pm  Registration and Coffee</p><p style="text-align: justify;">5.30
 pm  Introduction by Peter Leaver QC</p><p style="text-align: justify;">5.50
 pm  Comments by Professor Emmanuel Gaillard</p><p style="text-align: justif
 y;">6.10pm  Observations by Attorney General Sundaresh Menon</p><p style="t
 ext-align: justify;">6.20pm  Panel Discussion followed by Q&A</p><p style="
 text-align: justify;">7.00pm  Closing Remarks</p><p style="text-align: just
 ify;">7.10pm  Networking and Refreshments</p><p style="text-align: justify;
 "><strong>About the Chairman:</strong></p><p style="text-align: justify;">M
 r Menon, graduated with Bachelor of Laws (First Class Honours) from the Nat
 ional University of Singapore in 1986 and later obtained a Master of Laws d
 egree from Harvard Law School in 1991. He was admitted as an advocate and s
 olicitor of the Supreme Court of Singapore in 1987 and as an Attorney and C
 ounsellor-at-law of the Bar of the State of New York in 1992. He was appoin
 ted Senior Counsel in January 2008.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mr M
 enon is recognised as one of the leading lawyers in the fields of commercia
 l litigation and arbitration, insolvency and construction law, in Singapore
  and abroad. He has advised and represented numerous local and overseas cli
 ents in complex and technical disputes and served in arbitration tribunals 
 in various jurisdictions.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">From April 200
 6 to March 2007, Mr Menon served as a Judicial Commissioner of the Supreme 
 Court. After his stint at the Bench, he returned to Rajah & Tann becoming t
 he Managing Partner of that firm in August 2009, a position he held until h
 is appointment as the Attorney-General on 1 October 2010.</p><p style="text
 -align: justify;">During his term as Judicial Commissioner, he presided ove
 r several prominent criminal and civil cases in the High Court. He has also
  served as the Deputy Chairman of the Singapore International Arbitration C
 entre and has represented Singapore at UNCITRAL.</p><p style="text-align: j
 ustify;"><strong>About the Speaker:</strong></p><p style="text-align: justi
 fy;"><strong>Emmanuel Gaillard</strong> has represented corporations, State
 s and State-owned entities in international arbitration matters for over 25
  years. He has also acted as sole arbitrator, party-appointed arbitrator or
  chairman under most international arbitration rules, and is frequently cal
 led upon to appear as expert witness on arbitration law issues in internati
 onal arbitration proceedings or enforcement actions before domestic courts.
 </p><p style="text-align: justify;">Through his practice, extensive writing
  and teaching, Emmanuel Gaillard has significantly contributed to the shapi
 ng of contemporary international arbitration law. His publications include 
 Fouchard Gaillard Goldman On International Commercial Arbitration (1999), a
  leading treatise on international arbitration, La Jurisprudence du CIRDI (
 2 volumes, 2004 and 2010), a commentary on ICSID case law; and the first es
 say on the legal theory of international arbitration, based on his Course a
 t The Hague Academy of International Law (Aspects philosophiques du droit d
 e l'arbitrage international, 2008; Legal Theory of International Arbitratio
 n, 2010; Teoría Legal del Arbitraje Internacional, 2010). Emmanuel Gaillard
  is a Professor of Law at Paris XII University. He heads Shearman & Sterlin
 g LLP's International Arbitration practice.</p><p style="text-align: justif
 y;"><strong>Peter Leaver</strong> is an experienced international commercia
 l arbitrator, recommended in Chambers and Partners and The Legal 500. He is
  a member of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (MCIArb) and appointed 
 to The Law Society’s Accreditation Panel of Arbitrators.</p><p style="text-
 align: justify;">Through his extensive practice at the Bar, Peter Leaver is
  experienced in banking, insurance and financial services cases, and relate
 d jurisdictional questions. He was a director of IMRO between 1994 and 2000
 , and a Deputy Chairman of the Regulatory Decisions Committee of the Financ
 ial Services Authority until 2005. He is a Deputy High Court Judge. He was 
 a member of a SIB Working Party on the responsibilities of Senior Executive
 s, and was on the Selection Panel for the F.S.A. Ombudsman Board. Between 1
 997 and 1999 he took a sabbatical from the Bar and was Chief Executive of t
 he F.A. Premier League.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">In addition to h
 is experience in international commercial arbitration, Peter Leaver is an e
 xperienced arbitrator in the sports sector. He is a member of the Court of 
 Arbitration for Sport and was appointed as the only British member of the C
 ourt of Arbitration for Sport Adhoc Tribunal for UEFA 2000 and 2004, and th
 e FIFA World Cup 2006. He was appointed as a member of the Ad-hoc Division 
 of the Court of Arbitration for Sport for the Salt Lake City Olympic Winter
  Games 2002 and for the Turin Olympic Winter Games 2006. He is also appoint
 ed to the Chairman’s List of the Sports Dispute Resolution Panel (SDRP). He
  is Chairman of the Board of the London Court of International Arbitration,
  and the President of the National Anti-Doping Panel. Peter Leaver has a wo
 rking knowledge of French.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Download Broc
 hure <a href="images/Events/Seminar20110726.pdf" target="_blank">HERE</a></
 p>
CONTACT:SIArb Secretariat This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
				document.getElementById('cloak46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74').innerHTML = '';
				var prefix = '&#109;a' + 'i&#108;' + '&#116;o';
				var path = 'hr' + 'ef' + '=';
				var addy46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74 = 's&#101;cr&#101;t&#97;r&#105;&#97;t' + '&#64;';
				addy46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74 = addy46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74 + 's&#105;&#97;rb' + '&#46;' + '&#111;rg' + '&#46;' + 'sg';
				var addy_text46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74 = 's&#101;cr&#101;t&#97;r&#105;&#97;t' + '&#64;' + 's&#105;&#97;rb' + '&#46;' + '&#111;rg' + '&#46;' + 'sg';document.getElementById('cloak46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74').innerHTML += '<a ' + path + '\'' + prefix + ':' + addy46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74 + '\'>'+addy_text46bc7fa4029044835f89a3a1be8e8d74+'';
		
DTSTAMP:20261118T115247
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Singapore:20110726T170000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Singapore:20110726T191000
SEQUENCE:0
TRANSP:OPAQUE
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR